TREASURE MAPS
  • Home
  • Tracks
  • Writings
  • Artwork
  • Reviews
  • About
  • Links

Esgair Hir- chasing dreams of silver.

14/9/2018

4 Comments

 
Picture
The barracks, viewed from the hillside and looking south west towards Llyn Nantycagal.
Yet another fascinating site that we found while driving over from Cwm Ceulan towards Nant-y-Moch. What intrigued us initially were the remains of barracks for the workers at Esgair Hir and Esgair Fraith mines. Whilst exploring these buildings, a line of crown holes was spotted, climbing up the hillside. We felt sure that there would be something interesting over the ridge- and there was...

A little bit of history
The story of the mine begins in 1690, when Sir Carberry Pryse found an outcrop of silver ore on his land. He wanted to mine it himself, but fell foul of the Society of the Mines Royal, who had the monopoly of all gold and silver mines worth exploiting. He took the matter to court and won a landmark case- on the 8th February 1693, an Act of Parliament was passed, which removed Crown Ownership of mines containing gold and silver. This allowed local landowners to develop or lease mines on their own land.

Sir Carberry soon found that mining was expensive and he began to look for partners in the venture to help with the considerable financial exposure. He produced a fanciful estimate of profits for the mine which suggested that with 600 miners working and each one bringing half a ton of ore per week to the surface, the mine would yield a profit of £70,500 in the first year, after which more miners would be needed! If only mining were that simple.

There was silver, lead and copper to be had in the rock below, but the surrounding material was hard and there was also a problem with water ingress, something that would trouble all the companies who tried their luck with the mine. Carberry Pryse died in 1694, after which William Waller, the manager of the old company, issued some extravagant claims for the fortunes to be made here. Connoisseurs of mining history will not be surprised at the claims made- ‘the richest in all Wales'- or that a new company was floated called the "Company of Mines Adventurers of England" who, it is said, raised some 2000 tons of ore between 1703 and 1708.

There was the matter, also, of Waller calling the mine the "Welsh Potosi" after the incredibly wealthy Bolivian mine in the C17th and claiming that he was going to construct a town of the same name near the mine.

Four other companies attempted with various levels of success and duplicity to exploit the ore underground. Finally after 1886, a ragged group of partnerships stripped the place of any easily won mineral and combed the tips until 1904 when working ceased.

For a more thorough overview of the history, I wholeheartedly recommend Marilyn Palmer's monograph on the mine in the Northern Mine Research Society's series of papers. I will provide a link at the end.
Picture
One of the crown pits, with Petra for scale.
The Remains
We parked up at the start of an unsurfaced road at SN 72322 90958, this comes off the mountain road which was itself engineered by the mining company in 1840.
Walking along the road, the line of crown pits is easily seen. They are probably of some antiquity, dating from the earliest days of the mine and since each one represents a blocked shaft, considerable effort must have been expended. Below the line of shafts is an almost run-in adit, the West Level, which was driven under the auspices of William Waller in a hopeless attempt to drain the mine. It is still possible to see into the adit, but exploration is definitely not recommended.
Picture
The barracks, showing typical buttressing by miners more used to shoring up adits underground!
The barracks are an interesting range of structures, perhaps not big enough to house the six hundred men Pryse had in mind, but substantial none the less. A large single-pitched room seems to have been the kitchen and has the remains of a range. A turf house was situated nearby but there is no sign of that now. Standing next to the ruinous walls, open to the weather's attentions, it's hard to imagine the conversations that must have gone on here between the miners. It's a life that is difficult to imagine for most of us, few creature comforts, isolated on the moors for the week, longer in the winter when the snows blocked the pass.
Picture
The powder house, with the barracks in the background. The mine is behind the hill above the barracks.
I was pleased to find a ruined powder house on a knoll to the west of the barracks, a round pattern that now looks more like the nearby bronze age ring cairn of Carn Owen. Just under the access road are a couple of water wheel pits and run-in adits that may be from other mining enterprises, as the West Level is stated as the outer edge of the sett. Judging from the tips, these excavations were not fruitful.
Picture
The remains of the ore bins with the crusher house and engine house above.
Walking up to the bwlch which is the watershed of the Afon Lluestgota, more shafts are found, then a flat area which was at one time the site of ore bins and a processing floor. This has unfortunately suffered the attentions of the forestry commission and their roadmaking gangs. Mine tips are always easy pickings for road making, even if this one was a SSSI. There are other dark clouds on the horizon in the shape of the Scottish & Southern Energy (SSE) proposals, to build a wind power station of 62 turbines up to 481ft high – much larger than any yet built in the UK – on the foothills of Pumlumon overlooking the Nant y Moch reservoir. Several would be sited above Esgair Hir and I have no doubt that the tips and buildings at the mine would be ransacked for easy hard core.  The Cambrian Mountains Society is fighting hard against this- let's hope they are successful.
Picture
The engine house, looking west towards the Penybwlch shaft, fenced off in the background.
The ruins of a complicated looking structure are visible on the left- the engine house and crushing mill of 1872. The foundations to the left are probably for the boiler. On the right, long steel rods supported a winding wheel. As recently as 1979, there was a gable wall and window still standing here, but gales and rain have seen it off since. A little way off to the left is the finely engineered stonework of Shaft Glas, with a pump-rod tunnel designed to de-water the mine and then utilise the motion of the rods to power other machinery, two thirds of a mile away at Esgair Fraith.
Picture
Shaft Glas, with the pumping rod tunnel to the left.
Our visit terminated with a look at the mine offices and workshops, a long, low and ruinous structure whose claim to fame was that George Borrow sheltered here one night while on his travels, described in "Wild Wales". I managed somehow to not take a photo, so I am very grateful to Chris Andrews for his excellent shot. Nearby is the opencut of Shaft Moses, filled now with rubble, old washing machines and bits of car.
Sadly, we ran out of time on our visit, but will conclude the article with a description of Esgair Fraith as soon as we can.

References:
Welsh Mines Preservation Trust survey

British Mining No.22- "The Richest in all Wales" by Marilyn Palmer, available as a purchaseable download from the Northern Mine Research Society here.
Picture
The flat rod line from the engine shaft- later a wire rope was utilised, running over dollys supported by posts driven into the ground.
Interior view of the barracks.
More crown holes, towards the top of the bwlch.
A notice, thrown on the ground near the mine.
The engine shaft pump rod tunnel.
The balance-bob pit for the Pen-y-bwlch shaft.
The remains of a trial shaft complete with balance-bob pit and wheelpit, underneath the access road. Probably the trial shaft sunk by Captain Sandars in 1862.
The engine house.
A stone in front (west) of the barracks- possibly a standing stone?
The Office, from the engine house. Copyright © Chris Andrews and licensed for reuse under this Creative Commons Licence
The site of Shaft Moses, in front of the mine offices.
4 Comments
Laura Foster
16/9/2018 02:35:44 am

I was fascinated by the (beautiful!) photo of the barracks interior with the various building materials. Where do you suppose the bricks came from? Would they have been created on-site? It seems so odd to see them in a building made of local slate...

Forgive my sudden new tangent...! but I think it's easy for the average person to consider ruins as useless structures, suitable for nothing except as building material. I remember reading about ancient buildings in Rome, Babylon, and others where locals had "cannibalized" the stone for use in their own buildings. It's a sad desecration for a sight-seer but occasionally necessary for survival for the locals... Where does the line get drawn?

This site: http://www.buildingconservation.com/articles/life-for-ruins/life-for-ruins.htm discusses various ways ruins have been actually incorporated into modern life, and the various issues that have to be rectified in some way. It's interesting to read these solutions, but it's doubtful any of them would be used in the Welsh wilderness... But to pull stones and potentially destroy these old buildings would be detrimental to society in my personal opinion. Once these buildings are gone, they're gone forever. I think it's a huge mistake to think only in terms of the future and insisting on modern conveniences, streamlining, etc. To forget our past, or brush it under the rug, is to lose our heritage. This quote says it quite nicely: [Heritage] "is the range of contemporary activities, meanings, and behaviors that we draw from them." from http://www.umass.edu/chs/about/whatisheritage.html

In this thought-vein I was again I was struck by your ability to "see" the original usage and placement of certain buildings based on simple foundations or tip locations or sizes. You've seen all different locales and observed, studied and wondered about the various elements of these mines and all that information allows you to see the history of these mines in a way few people today can... Gosh, you and Petra have even been deep underground delving into the innermost workings of these places. If local society groups need someone to speak on their behalf, I do hope they understand you could easily be their secret weapon!

Reply
Iain Robinson
16/9/2018 05:41:39 pm

Hi Laura, thank you so much for that lovely comment :-)
The bricks were from a brick and tile company in Newtown, which is about 25 miles away...they are heat resistant so would be a special order I guess...perhaps they came with a load of coal for the steam engine on site in the 1830s. There were also bricks in evidence in the crushing mill...I know that carts went away with ore and came back with materials, so I guess that was it. Slate and shale is not good where heat is an issue.
I agree with your thoughts entirely about cannibalising ruins...it has been done in some places, but is to be regretted. I like to see disused mills and factories re-used as flats etc, but to take them apart for spares is a bit disrespectful in my opinion. And yes, thankfully, it doesn't happen much with mines since they are usually in the back of beyond!
One of the things we both really enjoy is finding the powder houses, checking the structure against a range of indicators...a bit like hunting but with a happy ending :-). I am asked to speak at various meetings, although being very shy it is an ordeal I can do without. But I have many friends who are more eloquent than me, although it is kind of you to suggest I would be useful :-)
We still go underground a lot, but I tend now not to put the photos up except on Tumblr, where people can't ask me where they are, as I don't want folk hurting themselves or vandalising these places. Thanks so much for your very interesting comment and the link, and thanks for dropping in- I have more posts to write up this week :-)

Reply
Rachael
10/2/2019 07:50:16 pm

Hello
This is fascinating! Just been up to the lake here for an extremely cold winter swim and so interested to read about the history of the area. Do you have a map anywhere on your site with all the places you have written about? I have only found the list, so can't see easily where each one is. Thanks for sharing your knowledge of these extraordinary places!

Reply
Iain Robinson link
11/2/2019 08:44:15 am

Thank you for your comment, Rachael...you are a lot braver than me, swimming in lakes! I'll stick to roaming about underground, thank you :-) That's a good idea, a map of the sites I have visited...I will look into that....my partner Petra had a map on her site that was interactive, but I guess even a basic map would be helpful. Thanks for the excellent idea!

Reply

Your comment will be posted after it is approved.


Leave a Reply.

    Buy Me a Coffee at ko-fi.com
    If you enjoy my content, please consider supporting what I do. Buy me a coffee! Thank you :-)

    Tracks

    RSS Feed

    Index

    All
    Abercorris Quarry
    Aberglaslyn
    Aberglaslyn Mine
    Aberglaslyn Pen Y Gaer
    Allt Y Ceffylau
    Amnodd Wen Ruins
    Ancient Monuments
    Arenig
    Baron Hill
    Blaen Ceulan
    Blaen-y-Cwm
    Bryn Arian Mine
    Bryndyfi
    Brynkir Tower
    Bryn Y Felin
    Bulkeley Mansion
    Bwlch Glas Mine
    Bwlch Y Battel
    Cae'r Nant Quarry
    Cardigan Bay Consols
    Carn Bentrych
    Catherine And Jane
    Cedryn Slate Quarry
    Cefn Cam
    Chwarel Y Plas
    Cil Drysgwr
    Clearance Cairns
    Clee Hill
    Cnicht
    Coed Crafnant
    Coed Felinrhyd
    Conglog Mine
    Copper Mines
    Cors Y Fron
    Cwm Cipwrth
    Cwm Cyd Slate Trials
    Cwm Dulyn Hafods
    Cwm Dwyfor
    Cwm Eigiau Slate Quarry
    Cwmorthin
    Cwm Pennant
    Cwm Silyn Mine
    Cwm Y Llan Slate Quarry
    Cwm Yr Afon Mine
    Cyfanned
    Din Lligwy
    Dinorwig- A Close Shave
    Dinorwig-the Top Levels
    Dol-Ithan-Gethin
    Dorothea
    Dorothea Holman Pump House
    Dorothea- The End
    Eaglebrook Mine
    Environmental Concerns
    Esgair Hir Lead Mine
    Figra Mine
    Foel Grochan
    Foel Quarry
    Gellfechan
    Gold Mines
    Gorseddau Quarry
    Gorseddau Tramway
    Graiglwyd Part 2
    Graiglwyd Quarry
    Gwynfynydd
    Hafan Quarries
    Hafod-y-Porth
    Hafotty Fach
    Henfwlch Mine
    Highlights Of 2018
    Iron Mines
    Little Italy
    Lliwedd Copper Mine
    Llwyn Y Betws
    Lynniau Gamallt Mine
    Maen Y Bardd
    Maen Y Gaseg
    Megaliths
    Metal Mines
    Moelfre Slate Quarry
    Moel Hebog
    Moel Isallt
    Moel Ty Uchaf Stone Circle
    Moelwyn Bach Mine
    Moelwyn Slate Mine
    Nant Gefail-y-Meiars
    Nantlle Tramway
    On Stravaiging
    Pant Mawr Slate Quarry
    Peat Huts
    Pen Y Gaer
    Plas Bryncir
    Pont Scethin
    Prehistoric Sites
    Prince Of Wales 1
    Prince Of Wales 2
    Ratgoed
    Ratgoed Part 2
    Remains Of (back In) The Day
    Rhos Quarry
    Rhosydd
    Rhosydd And Cwmorthin: 1
    Ruins
    Serw Slate Quarry
    Slate
    South Snowdon Slate Qy
    Tal-eithin Uchaf
    Talmierin Mine
    Tal Y Fan Quarry
    Tan Y Graig Quarry
    The Alma Cavern
    Trecastell Mine
    Tyddyn Gwladys
    Vivian
    Wrysgan
    Y Lôn Goed
    Ystrad Einion
    Ystrad/Garreg Fawr

book reviews . writings . links  . blogger

© Iain Robinson and Treasure Maps, 2013-2030. Unauthorized use and/or duplication of this material without express and written permission from this site’s author and/or owner is strictly prohibited. Excerpts and links may be used, provided that full and clear credit is given to Iain Robinson and Treasure Maps with appropriate and specific direction to the original content.

​The depiction of a mine or site does not indicate that access is possible- permission should be sought before entering any private land.
Underground exploration should not be undertaken unless properly equipped and with at least one experienced member of the party.
  • Home
  • Tracks
  • Writings
  • Artwork
  • Reviews
  • About
  • Links